
Alien Earth (a couple of small spoilers) Damn, this was almost so good. The cast and the characters were great - there was good social commentary and everyone's motivations for their actions made sense. The direction and the music were awesome - it created an incredible sense of atmosphere and intense psychological drama that really drew me in. The look of it and the effects were fantastic.
There were just too many big flaws in the plotting for me to really love it. You have a high biosecurity alien containment lab, but someone stupid can open a door to one of the alien enclosures without any alarms going off. The idiot kid who cannot keep his mouth shut the entire series and is constantly on the edge of telling everyone they meet the incredibly important secret they must never mention - that kid somehow doesn't tell anybody when the guy who almost killed them starts talking inside his head. Once it becomes direct blackmail, it makes sense - but the kid saying nothing for days before that? Not a chance.
These are flaws that really wouldn't have needed much fixing. The plot could still have worked out the same way in the end with just a little more care taken with the plot devices, and it would have made a world of difference to the overall quality.
Peacemaker season 2 More of the same, and the same is gold. Genuinely funny, genuinely moving, absolutely insane. I love this cast, and James Gunn's writing is fantastic.
Some people were annoyed about the ending, I know, but the ending itself works with the plot and the situations it has set up. The only thing annoying about it to me is that there aren't any plans for a season three - the intent is to continue that storyline in crossovers with other James Gunn media. And that annoys the fuck out of me, because this story and these characters deserve to be given another season entirely their own 😭
Person of Interest season 3 OMG, this season really pushed the boat out with Carter. She rocked, and she deserved all of it. It was something they sorely needed to do with her, and I'm so glad they did. Her relationship with Elias was awesome (I'm really liking Elias more and more as the series goes on). I was not expecting the mid-season twist, that was A Thing.
Still really liking both Finch and Reese, and Shaw is making the most of all the potential I thought she had as a character, I love her ❤️. Root remains a) too crazy and b) too much of a plot device. They've chosen an interesting way to try and rehab her personality, but unlike the rest of the cast, she has no explanation for her skillset. A certain amount of things you can achieve just by following instructions in real time, but other things take rather more than that... But right now, she's the only weak spot in a very solid and entertaining series. Onward to season four...
Only Murders in the Building season 5 More of the same, and it's starting to get a little too same-y. It's fine; it's entertaining on a superficial level, but there are a limited number of places they can go with this, and five seasons in, those limitations are becoming very apparent. Martin Short and Meryl Strep continue to make an absolutely adorable screen couple, though - their scenes are perfection.
What We Do in the Shadows season 6 I finally got around to watching this, after the deeply underwhelmed reactions of the fans on my tumblr dash pushed it down the priority list. Overall, it's not bad, just kind of meh. Like Only Murders, there are inherent limitations with the format, and the writers tried to get around those somewhat with the office corporate culture plotline and satire, but it only partly worked. It was definitely time for this to end.
I wasn't a fan of the ending ending, where they tried to be all things to all people by offering multiple options in a total cop-out. You can't give a maybe wink wink nudge on the ship you've been teasing for years and expect people to be happy with that. I'm not even a shipper for them and it was irritating. Please, just choose the ending you think it needs and commit.
Star Trek: Strange New Worlds season 3 (a couple of small spoilers) Overall, I enjoy Strange New Worlds, but I have to think of it as Not Trek. If I treat it like The Orville, something clearly Trek-inspired but not actually Trek, most of the time it's a lot of fun. It has a great cast generally, and Anson Mount's Pike is fantastic. But this is not Spock and it's not Kirk. I understand the general irritation with a Spock who bounces from het romance to het romance (see also This Is Not Spock) but Spock and La'An make a lot more sense as a couple than Spock and Chapel ever did, so that's an improvement.
As in previous seasons, it was very up and down. The last two eps in particular were genuinely good stuff, with actual emotional impact. Sure, one of them was just a rewrite of Enemy Mine, but it was written and acted well, and that's the detail that matters when you're borrowing. Episode five, meanwhile, was some of the most godawful writing I've seen since the final season of Game of Thrones. I'm talking 'fanfic written by a thirteen year old' level drivel. These people are supposed to be trained professionals! They have an actual professional archaeologist with them! And yet they discover a lost temple from an ancient civilisation and a random group of people go bumbling all around inside, touching everything and documenting nothing. Then when one of the random touchy people gets zapped by a glowy orb and collapses, they beam him up to sick bay. Do they put him in an isolation ward? Nah, the put him in a standard bed. Does the doctor treating him wear PPE? Nah, why would you bother doing that when dealing with unknown alien shit? Please. That script should never have made it past the initial pitch. Hard to believe somebody actually got paid for it... 😡